With Yao already starting at center, and Marcus Camby presumed to be a lock in at one of the backup spots. It can only be assumed that one other center would be taken in the west. Does Amare Stoudermire deserve it for being one of 3 centers averaging over 20 PPG. Or does Chris Kaman deserve for having a monster year so in points, blocks, rebounds and 20-20 games?
I say Chris Kaman will be chosen over Amare
Amare has been lit up all yea on the defensive end and that will probably hurt his case
Kaman’s averaging like 18 points, 14 rebounds, 3 blocks…those are monster numbers.
He should be in the game over Amare
everyone in his team has been injury and he has been the only bright spot and he has been doing all this on his own even through his teammates’ inconsistent play…can’t say that for Amare who has good teamates who set him up such as Nash, Marion and Barbosa
Right Back at Ya | Jan 24, 2008
KAMAN
Dorineous | Jan 24, 2008
You have to pass on Kaman, and take Amare. Stoudamire can play the PF spot, and run. The all star game is all about excitement & fast breaks. Stoudamire is a high flyer who will bring fans out of their seats…thats why i think he goes.
Amare- 23 pts,9 reb’s
Kaman- 17 pts, 14 reb
The west already has enough big bodies with Yao,Camby,Duncan…so look what Amare brings…even though Kaman deserves it. The Nba might find a way for both to go…
DOL-FAN | Jan 24, 2008
Amare Stoudemire
i think chris kaman is overrated.
Old Man | Jan 24, 2008
Amare because the NBAs about money and more people would want Amare because hes more exciting with his dunks and everything
bruuuahhh | Jan 24, 2008
Kaman is having an amazing year. Unfortunately for him, so is Amare, and Stoudemire plays on a much better team and that typically sways those making those choices. In an ideal world, they’d both be there.
joss1925 | Jan 24, 2008
stoudemire is better on the paint than kaman
go w/ stoudemire
anthony f | Jan 24, 2008
I would choose Chris Kaman over Marcus Camby because of his ability to score for a center while his rebounds and blocks production are pretty similar to the Camby man. Amare Stoudemire should also be selected because he’s one of the few big men in the league who consistently racks in 20-10-2 night in / night out.
JR | Jan 24, 2008
Easier question? Which one is better? It’s an All-Star game not a what you have done for me lately game. A player can’t go into the All-Star game for doing what some other player has already done. Amare Stoudemire is must likely going to get a reserve and Clippers are horrible this year.
I really like Marcus Camby and hope he does get in but I just don’t see it, with only 7 spots open. Remember the coaches pick the best players at their respective positions only.
East of Torrance | Jan 24, 2008
Amare
Mr Seven | Jan 24, 2008